Skip to main content
TAGS

How to Train Leaders (Hint: Train Disciples)

At a time when many church leaders struggle to find candidates to train into ministry leadership, Andrew Mitchell has successfully identified—and mentored—many. 

One of the most pressing issues facing the church in Aotearoa New Zealand is the lack of emerging leaders coming up through the ranks. Arguably the most striking and sobering recent finding from the most recent Church Life Survey (2023) was how much older the church population is than the general population in this country. You don’t have to be a statistician to know that that means for church leadership: it’s going to get harder to fill the gap left by the outgoing leaders as their ministry careers taper off. The church is facing a leadership crisis.

Recognising this, many church leaders are eager to train up younger leaders in their own context, but lament the lack of suitable candidates. Not Andrew Mitchell though. The pastor of Napier Baptist Church has a near-constant stream of congregants enrolled at Pathways, some of whom have subsequently stepped into positions of ministry leadership—and with many others who are well on their way. He had a similar modus operandi at his previous post, Church on Vogel in Palmerston North. The number of students he has put through Pathways as a pastor now totals 31.

Andrew preaches what he practiced. He himself made a mid-career shift, which started with enrolling at Pathways for a year of transformational biblical study. Ever since, he’s been a fierce advocate for encouraging his own congregants into theological study, particularly at Pathways. “I did [Pathways] when I was 45,” recalls Andrew. “That was the trajectory that took me to pastoring. I’ll talk to anybody about doing an internship and see if they’ve got the space to give a year.”

“We’ll take years off to study for a career or go for an O.E.,” he continues. “Yet we’re talking about the gospel, we’re talking about Jesus, we’re talking about the kingdom—why wouldn’t you take a year off to build a foundation of scripture, to develop your giftings and abilities in terms of your practical skill-base?”

The Secret to Success in Training Leaders

But in an age where so many church leaders struggle to identify emerging leaders, how does Andrew do it?

Perhaps the real secret to his success in training leaders is this: he doesn’t seek to train leaders at all—he wants to train disciples. Biblical and theological study is valuable for almost every follower of Christ, not just those who are obviously leadership material. “I just look at anyone and everyone,” Andrew says. “I just think everyone should do it.”

Yet the leaders still emerge. When large numbers of your church are going through Bible college, it’s inevitable that leaders will rise to the surface. Andrew has mentored Pathways graduates who have gone on to become pastors and heads of parachurch ministries. Of course, many are serving solely in non-leadership roles. Yet even many of those graduates are on track to become senior leaders within their churches.

Keeping an Open Mind to Who

Keeping an open mind about who to encourage into Bible college is fundamental to Andrew’s approach. “You look at where [an intern’s] strengths are,” says Andrew. “Because sometimes we say ‘this is what we want to run and who’s going to run it?’ as opposed to, ‘Actually, you’ve got these skills, if you ran something in this space, that’d be so cool.’”

Andrew’s interns have been involved in a range of activities that are, in many instances, structured around that person’s individual gifts and experience. Instead of looking for the all-too-rare “unicorns”, the obvious future leaders, Andrew thinks broadly. He encourages a wide variety of people into formal study, and treats an intern’s outside-the-box skills as opportunities for left-field sorts of ministry. One student, a former boxer, ran a boxing ministry during his internship.

Reflecting further on what goes in to assessing a congregant’s suitability for study, Andrew says, “They have to be academic to a certain degree, but I think Pathways is really good at not making it too out of reach for people . . . You don’t have to be high-level in terms of ministry; you just need to have that willing heart to serve and grow.”

If more church leaders were to adopt Andrew’s approach, then who knows? Our leadership crisis might turn into a leadership comeback.



 

This product has been added to your cart

CHECKOUT